Turbine inlet temperatures over the next few years will approach 1650°C (3000°F) at maximum power for the latest large commercial turbofan engines, resulting in high fuel efficiency and thrust levels approaching 445 KN (100,000 lbs.). High reliability and durability must be intrinsically designed into these turbine engines to meet operating economic targets and ETOPS certification requirements. This level of performance has been brought about by a combination of advances in air cooling for turbine blades and vanes, design technology for stresses and airflow, single crystal and directionally solidified casting process improvements, and the development and use of rhenium (Re) containing high γ′ volume fraction nickel-base superalloys with advanced coatings, including full-airfoil ceramic thermal barrier coatings. Re additions to cast airfoil superalloys not only improves creep and thermo-mechanical fatigue strength, but also environmental properties including coating performance. Re dramatically slows down diffusion in these alloys at high operating temperatures. A team approach has been used to develop a family of two nickel-base single crystal alloys (CMSX-4® containing 3 percent Re and CMSX®-10 containing 6 percent Re) and a directionally solidified, columnar grain nickel-base alloy (CM 186 LC® containing 3 percent Re) for a variety of turbine engine applications. A range of critical properties of these alloys is reviewed in relation to turbine component engineering performance through engine certification testing and service experience. Industrial turbines are now commencing to use this aero developed turbine technology in both small and large frame units in addition to aero-derivative industrial engines. These applications are demanding, with high reliability required for turbine airfoils out to 25,000 hours, with perhaps greater than 50 percent of the time spent at maximum power. Combined cycle efficiencies of large frame industrial engines are scheduled to reach 60 percent in the U. S. ATS programme. Application experience to a total 1.3 million engine hours and 28,000 hours individual blade set service for CMSX-4 first stage turbine blades is reviewed for a small frame industrial engine.

Issue Section:
Gas Turbines: Manufacturing, Materials, and Metallurgy
Topics:
Blades, Crystals, Gas turbines, Superalloys, Engines, Alloys, Turbines, Airfoils, Nickel, Coatings, Reliability, Turbine blades, Air flow, Casting, Ceramics, Combined cycles, Cooling, Creep, Design, Diffusion (Physics), Durability, Fatigue strength, Fuel efficiency, Operating temperature, Stress, Teams, Temperature, Testing, Thermal barrier coatings, Thermomechanics, Thrust, Turbine components, Turbofans
1.
Bachelet, E., and Lamanthe, G., 1986, National Symposium—Single Crystal Superalloys, Viallard-de-Lans, France.
2.
Blavette, D., Caron, P., and Khan, T., Scripta Met, Vol. 20, No. 10.
3.
Blavette, D., Caron, P., and Khan, T., “An Atom-Probe Study of Some Fine Scale Microstructural Features in Ni-Base Single Crystal Superalloy,” 6th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 305–314.
4.
Brentnall, W. D., Aurrecoechea, J. M., Rimlinger, C. M., Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., Wahl, J. B., 1997, “Extensive Industrial Gas Turbine Experience With Second Generation Single Crystal Alloy Turbine Blades,” ASME (IGTI) Turbo Expo ’97, ASME, NY.
5.
Burkholder, P. S., Thomas, M. C., Frasier, D. J., Whetstone, J. R., Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., Sikkenga, S. L., and Eridon, J. M., 1995, “Allison Engine Testing CMSX-4 Single Crystal Turbine Blades and Vanes,” IOM 3rd International Charles Parsons Turb. Conf. Proc.,
6.
Caruel, F., Bourguignon, S., Lallement, B., Fargeas, S., DeBussac, A., Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., and Wahl, J. B., 1996, “SNECMA Experience With Cost Effective DS Airfoil Technology Applied Using CM 186 LC™ Alloy,” Turbine Development and Application, ASME, NY.
7.
Cetel, A. D., and Duhl, D. N., 1992, “Second Generation Columnar Grain Nickel-Base Superalloy,” 7th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 287–296.
8.
Cetel, A. D., and Duhl, D. N., 1988, “Second-Generation Nickel-Base Single Crystal Superalloy,” 6th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 235–244.
9.
Chen, J. H., and Little, J. A., 1995, unpublished work, Cambridge University, UK.
10.
Doner, M., and Heckler, J. A., 1985, “Effects of Section Thickness and Orientation on the Creep-Rupture Properties of Two Advanced Single Crystal Alloys,” Aerospace Technical Conference.
11.
Erickson, G. L., 1996, “The Development and Application of CMSX-10,” 8th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 35–44.
12.
Ford, D. A., and Arthey, R. P., 1984, “Development of Single Crystal Alloys for Specific Engine Application,” 5th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 115–124.
13.
Fullagar
K. P. L.
,
Bromfield
R. W.
,
Hulands
M.
,
Harris
K.
,
Erickson
G. L.
, and
Sikkenga
S. L.
,
1994
, “
Aero Engine Test Experience with CMSX-4™ Alloy Single Crystal Turbine Blades
,” 1996,
ASME JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING FOR GAS TURBINES AND POWER
, Vol.
118
, No.
2
, pp.
380
–
388
.
14.
Garrett, U. S. Patent #4, 935,072.
15.
Gell, M., Duhl, D. N., and Giamei, A. F., 1980, “The Development of Single Crystal Superalloy Turbine Blades,” 4th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 205–214.
16.
Gell, M., Duhl, D. N., Gupta, D. K., and Sheffler, K. D., 1987, JOM, pp. 11–15.
17.
Giamei, A. F., and Anton, D. L., 1985, “Rhenium Additions to a Ni-Base Superalloy: Effects On Microstructure,” Met Trans A. 16A, pp. 1997–2005.
18.
Goulette, M. J., Spilling, P. D., and Arthey, R. P., 1984, “Cost Effective Single Crystals,” 5th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 167–176.
19.
Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., and Schwer, R. E., 1983, “Development of the Single Crystal Alloys CMSX-2 and CMSX-3 For Advanced Technology Turbines,” ASME Paper no. 83-GT-244.
20.
Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., and Schwer, R. E., 1984, “MAR M 247 Derivations—CM 247 LC® DS Alloy, CMSX® Single Crystal Alloys, Properties and Performance,” 5th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 221–230.
21.
Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., and Schwer, R. E., 1986, “CMSX Single Crystal, CM DS and Integral Wheel Alloys Properties and Performance,” Cost 50/501 Conf. Lie´ge, Proc., pp. 709–728.
22.
Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., and Schwer, R. E., Frasier, D. J., and Whetstone, J. R., 1990, “Process and Alloy Optimization for CMSX-4 Superalloy Single Crystal Airfoil,” Cost Conference Lie´ge, Proc. Part II, pp. 1281–1300.
23.
Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., Sikkenga, S. L., Brentnall, W. D., Aurrecoechea, J. M., and Kubarych, K. G., 1992, “Development of the Rhenium Containing Superalloys CMSX-4 and CM 186 LC For Single Crystal Blade and Directionally Solidified Vane Applications in Advanced Turbine Engines,” 7th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 297–306.
24.
Holmes, J. W., et al., and O’Hara, K. S., 1988, “Thermal Fatigue Testing of Coated Monocrystalline Superalloys,” ASTM STP 942, ASTM, West Conshohocken, PA, pp. 672–691.
25.
Khan, T., and Brun, M., 1989, Symposium on Single Crystal Alloys, MTU/SMCT, Munich.
26.
Korinko, P. S., Barber, M. J., and Thomas, M. C., 1996, “Coating Characterization and Evaluation of DS CM 186 LC and SX CMSX-4,” Coatings/Materials Interactions, ASME, NY.
27.
Kubarych, K. G., and Aurrecoechea, J. M., 1993, “Post Field Test Evaluation of an Advanced Industrial Gas Turbine First Stage Turbine Blade,” TMS/ASM Mat Wk ’93 Proc., TMS, Warrendale, PA.
28.
Meyer-Olbersleben, F., Re´zai-Aria, F., and Goldschmidt, D., 1992, “Investigation of the Thermal Fatigue Behavior of Single Crystal Nickel-Based Superalloys SRR 99 and CMSX-4,” 7th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 785–794.
29.
Meyer-Olbersleben, F., Engler-Pinto, Jr., C. C., and Re´zai-Aria, F., 1996, “On Thermal Fatigue of Nickel-Based Superalloys,” Thermomechanical Fatigue Behavior of Materials, 2nd Vol., ASTM STP 1263 M. J. Verrilli and M. G. Castelli, eds., ASTM, West Conshohocken, PA.
30.
Miglietti, W. M., and Pennefather, R. C., 1996, Coatings/Materials Interactions, ASME, NY.
31.
Pessah, M., Caron, P., and Khan, T., 1992, “Effect of μ Phase on The Mechanical Properties of a Nickel-Base Single Crystal Superalloy,” 7th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 567–576.
32.
Petrov, D. A., and Tumanov, A. T., 1973, “The Use of Single Crystal Blades,” Aircraft Engineering No. 9.
33.
Pollack
T. M.
, and
Argon
A. S.
,
1992
,
Acta Metallurgica at Materialia
, Vol.
40
, pp.
1
1
.
34.
PW 2037 Engine Display, 1994, Farnborough Air Show (PWA), Pratt & Whitney.
35.
Roan, F., 1996, private communication.
36.
Ross, E. W., and O’Hara, K. S., 1996, “Rene´ N4: A First Generation Single Crystal Turbine Airfoil Alloy With Improved Oxidation Resistance, Low Angle Boundary Strength and Superior Long Time Rupture Strength,” 8th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 19–25.
37.
Ross, E. W., and O’Hara, K. S., 1992, “Rene´ 142: A High Strength, Oxidation Resistant DS Turbine Airfoil Alloy,” 7th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 257–265.
38.
Strangman, T. E., et al., 1980, “Development of Exothermically Cast Single Crystal MAR M 247 and Derivative Alloys,” 4th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 215–224.
39.
Thomas, M. C., Helmink, R. C., Frasier, D. J., Whetstone, J. R., Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., Sikkenga, S. L., and Eridon, J. M., 1994, “Allison Manufacturing, Property and Turbine Engine Performance of CMSX-4 Single Crystal Airfoils,” Cost 501 Conf Proc, Lie´ge.
40.
Walston, W. S., O’Hara, K. S., Ross, E. W., Pollock, T. M., and Murphy, W. H., 1996, “Rene´ N6: Third Generation Single Crystal Superalloy,” 8th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 27–34.
41.
Wortmann, J., Wege, R., Harris, K., Erickson, G. L., and Schwer, R. E., 1988, “Low Density Single Crystal Superalloy CMSX-6®,” 7th World Conference on Investment Casting Proc., Munich.
42.
Wukusick, C. S., and Buchakjian, L., Jr., 1991, “Improved Property—Balanced Nickel-Base Superalloys for Producing Single Crystal Articles,” UK Patent Application no. GB 2 235 697 A.
43.
Wukusick, C. S., 1980, Directional Solidification Alloy Development, final report, NAVAIR Contr. N62269-78-C-0315.
44.
Yamazaki, M., et al., 1984, “Alloy Design for High Strength Nickel-Base Single Crystal Alloys,” 5th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 157–166.
45.
Yukawa, N., et al., 1988, “High Performance Single Crystal Superalloys Developed By The d-Electrons Concept,” 6th International Symposium, TMS, Warrendale, PA, pp. 225–234.
This content is only available via PDF.
Copyright © 1998
 by The American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.