Abstract

The main objective of this study is to determine if the remains of Father Bachelot, leader of the first Catholic missionary group to the Hawaiian Islands, can be identified among the commingled human skeletal remains brought back from Pohnpei, Caroline Islands, Federated States of Micronesia, in 1977. An osteological/forensic examination of these remains, a review of the literature, interviews with leaders of the expedition, and ancillary considerations suggest that, in all probability, none of the skeletal remains from Pohnpei are those of Father Bachelot.

Father Alexis Bachelot, born in France, in 1796, was leader of the first Catholic missionary group to the Hawaiian Islands. He died in 1837, after being exiled from the Hawaiian Kingdom. His remains were buried on the small islet of Na, off the coast of Pohnpei, the same year. An expedition to Pohnpei in 1977, to recover the remains of Father Bachelot, resulted in the recovery of several sets of commingled remains which are the subject of this study.

A detailed osteological/forensic study of these remains indicates the presence of at least ten individuals, including two subadults, two adult females, and six adult males. Stature estimates, the presence of osseous changes suggestive of treponemal disease, and other cranial, dental, and skeletal features are more consistent with Pohnpean than European ancestry. The presence of shell beads and other mortuary features strengthens this assertion. Recommendations for any future attempts to recover the remains of this famous personage are made.

References

1.
Whelan
H A
.
The Picpus story
.
Pomona (CA)
,
Apostolate of Christian Renewal
,
1980
.
2.
Yzendoorn
R
.
History of the catholic mission in the Hawaiian Islands
.
Honolulu
,
Honolulu Star Bulletin
,
1927
.
3.
Alkire
W H
.
An introduction to the people and cultures of Micronesia
. Adison-Wesley Modular Publication Number 18,
1972
.
4.
Davison
J
.
Preliminary archaeological investigations on Ponape and other eastern Caroline Islands
.
Micronesica
1967
;
3
:
81
-
95
.
5.
Christian
F W
.
The Caroline Islands
.
London
,
Methuen
,
1899
.
6.
Hambruch
P
.
Ponape: die Ruinen
. In
Ergebnisse der Sudsee-Expedition 1908–1910
.
G.
Thilenius
. Vol.
II
. B vii.
Hamburg
,
Friederichsen, DeGruyter
,
1936
.
7.
Krogman
W M
,
İşcan
M Y
.
The human skeleton in forensic medicine
. 2nd ed.
Springfield (IL)
,
Charles C Thomas
,
1986
.
8.
Bass
W M
.
Human osteology. A laboratory and field manual of the human skeleton
. 3rd ed.
Columbia (MO)
,
Missouri Archaeological Society
,
1987
.
9.
Todd
T W
.
Age changes in the pubic bone. I: The white male pubis
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
1920
;
3
:
285
-
334
.
10.
McKern
T W
,
Stewart
T D
.
Skeletal age changes in young american males, analyzed from the standpoint of age identification
.
Environmental Protection Research Division (Quartermaster Research and Development Center, U.S. Army
, Natick, MA), Technical Report EP-45,
1957
.
11.
Brooks
S T
,
Suchey
J M
.
Skeletal age determination based on the os pubis: A comparison of the Acsádi-Nemeskéri and Suchey-Brooks Methods
.
Human Evolution
1990
;
5
:
227
-
38
.
12.
Katz
D
,
Suchey
J
.
Age determination of the male os pubis
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
1986
;
69
:
427
-
35
.
13.
Lovejoy
C O
,
Meindl
R S
,
Pryzbeck
T R
,
Mensforth
R P
.
Chronological metamorphosis of the auricular surface of the ilium: A new method for the determination of adult skeletal age at death
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
1985
;
68
:
15
-
28
.
14.
İşcan
M Y
,
Loth
S R
,
Wright
K R
.
Age estimation from the rib by phase analysis: White males
.
J Forensic Sci
1984
;
29
:
1094
-
104
.
15.
İşcan
M Y
,
Loth
S R
,
Wright
K R
.
Age estimation from the rib by phase analysis: White females
.
J Forensic Sci
1985
;
30
:
853
-
63
.
16.
Meindl
R S
,
Lovejoy
C O
.
Ectocranial suture closure. A revised method of the determination of skeletal age at death based on the lateral-anterior sutures
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
1985
;
68
:
57
-
66
.
17.
Houghton
P
,
Leach
B F
,
Sutton
D G
.
The estimation of stature of prehistoric Polynesians in New Zealand
.
J Polynesian Soc
1975
;
84
:
325
-
36
.
18.
Trotter
M
.
Estimation of stature from intact long limb bones
. In:
Stewart
T D
, editor.
Personal identification in mass disasters
.
Washington (DC)
,
National Museum of Natural History
,
1970
;
71
-
83
.
19.
Steele
D G
.
Estimation of stature from fragments of long limb bones
. In:
Stewart
T D
, editor.
Personal identification in mass disasters
.
Washington (DC)
,
National Museum of Natural History
,
1970
;
85
-
97
.
20.
Hooton
E A
.
Up from the ape
. Rev. ed.
New York
,
The Macmillan Co.
,
1963
.
21.
Martin
R
.
Lehrbuch der anthropologie
.
Stuttgart
,
Gustav Fischer
,
1957
.
22.
Olivier
G
.
Practical anthropology
.
Springfield (IL)
,
Charles C Thomas
,
1969
.
23.
Pietrusewsky
M
.
Craniometric variation in micronesia and the pacific: A multivariate study
.
Micronesica
1990
; Suppl
2
:
373
-
402
.
24.
Howells
W W
.
Cranial variation in man. Papers of the Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology
. Volume
67
.
Cambridge, MA
,
Harvard University
,
1973
.
25.
Rhine
S
.
Non-metric skull racing
. In:
Rhine
S
,
Gill
G W
, editors.
Skeletal attribution of race. Methods for forensic anthropology
.
Albuquerque NM
,
Maxwell Museum of Anthropology
, Anthropological Papers No. 4.
1990
;
9
-
20
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.