Abstract
The involvement of mental health professionals in determinations of dangerousness is both common and controversial. Among the various contexts for these evaluations, the release of potentially violent forensic patients from maximum security facilities evokes justified concern from involved experts and apprehension to outrage from the immediate community. We sought to examine how conclusions are reached on dangerousness at two sequential stages: clinical recommendations and Manifest Dangerousness Hearings decisions. In an archival study of 245 patients, we found that lack of progress in the institution and physical assaultiveness were the strongest correlates with dangerousness. In contrast, experts and review boards appeared to be relatively less influenced by diagnosis, types of treatment, and sociodemographic variables.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
References
1.
Cavanaugh
, J. L.
and Rogers
, R.
, “Convergence of Mental Illness and Violence: Effects on Public Policy
,” Psychiatric Annals
, Vol. 12
, 1982
, pp. 537
-541
.2.
Cocozza
, J. J.
and Steadman
, H. J.
, “The Failure of Psychiatric Predictions of Dangerousness: Clear and Convincing Evidence
,” Rutgers Law Review
, Vol. 29
, 1976
, pp. 1084
-1101
.3.
Kozol
, H. L.
, Boucher
, R. J.
, and Garfalo
, R. F.
, “The Diagnosis and Treatment of Dangerousness
,” Crime and Delinquency
, Vol. 19
, 1976
, pp. 554
-555
.4.
Quinsey
, V. L.
, Warnerford
, A.
, Pruesse
, M.
, and Link
, N.
, “Released Oak Ridge Patients: A Follow-Up Study of Review Board Discharges
,” British Journal of Criminology
, Vol. 15
, 1975
, pp. 264
-279
.5.
Steadman
, H. J.
, Cocozza
, J.
, and Melick
, M.
, “Explaining the Increased Crime Rate of Mental Patients: The Changing Clientele of State Hospitals
,” American Journal of Psychiatry
0002-953X, Vol. 135
, 1978
, pp. 816
-820
.6.
Thornberry
, T. P.
and Jacoby
, J. E.
, The Criminally Insane: A Follow-Up of Mentally Ill Offenders
, Chicago
, University of Chicago Press
, 1979
.7.
Menzies
, R. J.
, Webster
, C. D.
, McMain
, S.
, Staley
, S.
, and Scaglione
, R.
, “The Dimensions of Dangerousness Revisited: Assessing Forensic Decisions About Violence
,” Law and Human Behavior
0147-7307, Vol. 18
, 1994
, pp. 1
-28
.8.
Quinsey
, V.
and Maguire
, A.
, “Maximum Security Psychiatric Patients: Actuarial and Clinical Predictions of Dangerousness
,” Journal of Interpersonal Violence
, Vol. 1
, 1986
, pp. 143
-171
.9.
Cohen
, M. I.
, Spodak
, M. K.
, Silver
, S. B.
, and Williams
, K.
, “Predicting Outcome of Insanity Acquittees Released to the Community
,” Behavioral Sciences and the Law
, Vol. 6
, 1988
, pp. 515
-530
.10.
Litwack
, T. R.
and Schlesinger
, L. B.
, “Assessing and Predicting Violence: Research, Law and Application
,” In, I. B.
Weiner
and A. K.
Hess
, Eds., Handbook of Forensic Psychology
New York
, John Wiley & Sons
, 1987
, pp. 205
-257
.11.
Litwack
, T. R.
, Kirschner
, S. M.
, and Wack
, R. C.
, “The Assessment of Dangerousness and Predictions of Violence: Recent Research and Future Prospects
,” Psychiatric Quarterly
0033-2720, Vol. 64
, 1993
, pp. 245
-273
.12.
Miller
, M.
and Morris
, N.
, “Predictions of Dangerousness: An Argument for Limited Use
,” Violence and Victims
0886-6708, Vol. 3
, 1988
, pp. 263
-283
.13.
Werner
, P. D.
and Meloy
, J. R.
, “Decision Making About Dangerousness in Releasing Patients from Long-Term Psychiatric Hospitalizations
,” Journal of Psychiatry and Law
, Vol. 20
, 1992
, pp. 35
-47
.14.
Heilbrun
, K.
, “Risk Assessment with the MMPI-2 in Forensic Evaluations
,” Paper presented at the Sixth Kent State University Forum
, Millersburg, OH
, April, 1994.15.
Chen
, M. C. L.
, Gillis
, J. R.
, and Rogers
, R.
, “Treatability of Mentally Disorder Offenders: A Case Vignette Study of Psychiatrists' Treatment Recommendations
,” METFORS Working Paper #103, Clarke Institute of Psychiatry
, Toronto, 1988
.16.
Rogers
, R.
, Gillis
, J. R.
, McMain
, S.
, and Dickens
, S. E.
, “Fitness Evaluations: A Retrospective Study of Clinical, Legal and Sociodemographic Variables
,” Canadian Journal of Behavioral Science
, Vol. 20
, 1988
, pp. 192
-200
.17.
Tardiff
, K.
, “A Survey of Assault by Chronic Patients in a State Hospital System
,” Assaults with Psychiatric Facilities
, In, J. R.
Lion
and W. H.
Reid
, Eds., New York Grune and Stratton
, 1983
, pp. 3
-19
.18.
Lynett
, E.
and Rogers
, R.
, “Potential Bias in Dangerous Offender Hearings: Is Psychiatric Input Probative or Prejudicial?
,” Paper submitted for publication, 1992
.19.
Klassen
, D.
and O'Conner
, W. A.
, “Crime, Inpatient Admissions, and Violence Among Male Mental Patients
,” International Journal of Law and Psychiatry
0160-2527, Vol. 11
, 1988
, pp. 305
-312
.20.
Monahan
, J.
, Predicting Violent Behavior: An Assessment of Clinical Techniques
, Beverly Hills CA
, Sage
, 1981
.21.
Schwitzgebel
, R. K.
, “Professional Accountability in the Treatment and Release of Dangerous Persons
,” In Perspectives in Law and Psychology: Volume 1: The Criminal Justice System
, B. D.
Sales
, Ed., New York
, Plenum
, 1977
, pp. 139
-149
.
This content is only available via PDF.
All rights reserved. This material may not be reproduced or copied, in whole or in part, in any printed, mechanical, electronic, film, or other distribution and storage media, without the written consent of ASTM International.
You do not currently have access to this content.
