Abstract
In this research, the impact of structural parameters of bipolar plates on the proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cell performance has been investigated using numerical method, and this model incorporates all the essential fundamental physical and electrochemical processes occurring in the membrane electrolyte, cathode catalyst layer, electrode backing, and flow channel, with some assumptions in each part. In formulation of this model, the cell is assumed to work under steady state conditions. Also, since the thickness of the cell is negligible compared to other dimensions, one-dimensional and isothermal approximations are used. The structural parameters considered in this paper are: the width of channels (Wc), the width of support (Ws), the number of gas channels (ng), the height of channels (hc), and the height of supports (hp). The results show that structural parameters of bipolar plates have a great impact on outlet voltage in high current densities. Also, the number of gas channels, their surface area, the contacting area of bipolar plates, and electrodes have a great effect on the rate of reaction and consequently on outlet voltage. The model predictions have been compared with the existing experimental results available in the literature, and excellent agreement has been demonstrated between the model results and the experimental data for the cell polarization curve.
Introduction
The proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) is an electrochemical energy converter that converts chemical energy of fuel directly into DC electricity. A fuel cell using a very thin polymer membrane as an electrolyte has been considered as a promising candidate for future power sources, especially for transportation applications and residential power, due to their high efficiency, high power density, quick startup, quiet operations, and, most importantly, zero emissions, thereby reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.
The first demonstration of a fuel cell was by lawyer and scientist William Grove in 1839 [1], although it appears that a Swiss scientist Christian F. Shoenbein independently discovered the very same effect at about the same time (or even a year before) [2]. Optimizing of the geometrical parameters is one of the ways to minimize ohmic losses. Some studies have been developed to investigate the effect of using different channel configurations on cell performance. Sun et al. [3] developed a numerical study, which suggested using a trapezoidal channel cross-section rather than a rectangular or square cross-section to improve cell performance. Chiang and Chu [4] conducted numerical simulations of a 3D isothermal model of a PEMFC for various channel configurations (channel length, height, and shoulder width), with particular emphasis on the effect of channel height on cell performance. They carried out simulations with different combinations of channel width and height, while maintaining the same channel cross-sectional area and constant flow rate. Their results indicated that flat channels (i.e., smaller height) gave better performance.
Yi and Nguyen [5] developed an along-the-channel model for evaluating the effects of various designs and operating parameters on the performance of a PEM fuel cell. The results showed that the humidification of the anode gas is required to improve the conductivity of the membrane and the liquid injection and higher humidification temperature can enhance the cell performance. Ge and Yi [6] developed a two-dimensional model to investigate the effects of operation conditions and membrane thickness on the water transport. The results revealed that the cell performance can be enhanced by increasing the cell temperature. Yi and Nguyen [7] employed a two-dimensional isothermal model of a porous electrode to simulate the hydrodynamics of gas flow through the pore volume of the electrode of a PEMFC. It is concluded that, from the predictions of the PEM fuel cells with interdigitated flow field, the higher gas flow rate through the electrode improves the electrode performance. He et al. [8] and Kumar and Reddy [9,10] studied the influences of electrode and flow field design on the performance of a PEM fuel cell with a half-cell model. It was found that higher differential pressure between inlet and outlet channels would enhance the electrode performance. Kim et al. [11] developed a curve-fitting scheme based on experimental data of the first polarization curve of a PEM fuel cell. Ahmed and Sung [12] performed the simulations of PEMFCs with a new design for the channel shoulder geometry, in which the membrane electrode assembly is deflected from shoulder to shoulder. Bernardi and Verbrugge [13,14] used an analytical approach. They developed a mathematical model of a PEMFC from fundamental transport properties. Where the losses incurred by the activation over potential of the anode and cathode reaction, the ohmic losses incurred by the membrane and the ohmic losses due to the electrodes are subtracted from the reversible cell voltage. Marr and Li [15,16] developed a simplified engineering model of a PEMFC based on the catalyst layer of Weisbrod et al. [17] and the membrane model of Bernardi and Verbrugge [13,14]. This is the model that will be used to incorporate the effect of bipolar plate structural parameters on the PEMFC performance. Marr and Li [15] investigated the composition and performance optimization of cathode catalyst platinum and catalyst layer structure in a proton exchange membrane fuel cell by including both electrochemical reaction and mass transport process. They found that electrochemical reactions occur in a thin layer within a few micrometers thick, indicating ineffective catalyst utilization for the present catalyst layer design.
Also Baschuk and Li [18] investigated a polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell with variable degrees of water flooding of the membrane.
Therefore, the issue of bipolar structural parameters in a PEMFC has not been fully examined in the previous work. In the following sections, the formulation of the model will be presented. The result is then compared to experimental data available in the literature for validation.
Model Formulation
The operation of a PEM fuel cell is based on converting the chemical energy of the fuel, such as hydrogen, and oxidant, such as oxygen, into electrical energy, as shown in Fig. 1. The following electrochemical reactions happening on the anode and the cathode are the base of fuel cell function [19].
More precisely, the reactions above happen on a border between the ionically conductive electrolyte and electrically conductive electrode. The electrodes must be porous, allowing the gases to arrive to, as well as product water to leave, the reaction sites, because there are gases involved in fuel cell electrochemical reactions.
In the formulation of this model, the cell is assumed to work under steady state conditions. Also, since the thickness of the cell is negligible compared to its other dimensional, one-dimensional and isothermal approximation is used.
where Er is the reversible cell voltage and ηact is the loss due to resistance to the mass transfer limitations and electrochemical reactions in the cathode catalyst layer.
Electrode.
where hp is the thickness of the solid portion of the plate and hc is the height of the flow channels and supports. W and L are the width and length of the cell, respectively, and ws is the width of the channels supports.
where wc refers to the width of the flow channels and ws is the width of support, while ng is the number of the flow channels in the cell.
where Iδ is the cell current density.
Catalyst.
The catalyst layer is modeled with a set of coupled differential equations. In modeling the cathode catalyst layer, it is assumed to be isothermal, one-dimensional, and uniformly distributed. In this model, the other important assumption is that the negated space within the catalyst layer is large enough so that Knudsen diffusion is unimportant [18].
where I is the protonic current density, C is the concentration of oxygen, ηact is the over potential caused mostly by the resistance to the electrochemical reactions and due to the finite rate of mass diffusion, and z is the distance into the catalyst layer measured from the electrode/catalyst layer interface. io,ref denotes the reference current density that is a function of the cell temperature. Also, it is an experimentally derived parameter and is given as a function of temperature for Nafion on platinum in Parthasarathy et al. [21]. Also, γ, reaction order, can be found analytically from the procedure in Newman [22], with a value of 0.5 resulting.
mpt is the catalyst mass loading per unit area of the cathode, δc is the thickness of the catalyst layer, and As is the catalyst surface area per unit mass of the catalyst.
ρpt and ρc are the density of the platinum and its carbon support, and fpt represents the amount of platinum catalyst on its carbon support.
In this model, the mass transfer of oxygen from the flow channel to the reaction site of the cathode catalyst layer will determine the shape of the polarization curve in the concentration over the potential region [18].
Membrane.
In this equation, δm is the thickness of the membrane, Km is the electrical conductivity of the membrane, which is a function of cell temperature, Kp is the hydraulic permeability, KE is the electrokinetic permeability, ΔPa-c is the pressure differential across the membrane, CH+ is the fixed charge concentration, and denotes the viscosity of liquid water. The values for the Km, Kp, CH+, and KE for Nafion can be found in Bernardi and Verbrugge [13,14].
Bipolar Plate.
In a typical frame and PEM cell, the bipolar plate is a plate of graphic with a serpentine flow channel cut into it. These channels are used to deliver reactants to the electrode and to collect current from the electrode. Two different phenomena are modeled in the plate:
- (1)
Mass transport in the flow channel
- (2)
Electric resistance in the plate
Channel Flow.
In this equation, ΔC1 = Cs – Cinlet represents the inlet concentration difference and ΔC2 = Cs – Coutlet represents the outlet concentration difference.
For the second group of terms, it is assumed that ws has the same distance with respect to both length and width. Also, ohmic resistance, which is calculated in Sec. 2.1, is assumed constant within the temperature range 300–370 K, and diffusion is assumed to spread O2 evenly throughout the electrode surface such that there is a constant O2 concentration at the electrode catalyst layer interface.
Boundary Conditions.
The procedure for solving the formulated model to yield a cell voltage for given structural and operational parameters is as follows: first, the reversible voltage of the cell is calculated for the reference temperature and pressure (T = 60 °C, P = 5 atm) using Eq. (5). Then, the losses are calculated in all parts of the cell for calculating overall cell voltage in Eq. (3). Also, for calculating the catalyst influence on overall cell voltage, it is needed to solve ordinary differential equations consisting of Eqs. (14), (16), and (21) along with boundary conditions, which are stated for the catalyst layer in Eqs. (38), (41), and (43) that represent a two-point boundary value problem. The built-in shooting method algorithm within the boundary value problems function of the Matlab software package has been used for the present computation [27].
Validation
The polarization curve is obtained from the present calculations in base case condition (T = 353.15 K, P = 5 atm), except with mPt = 0.35 mg/cm2 (f = 10 Pt/C Mass %) and ROhmic = 0.225 (Ω/cm2), and is compared with the experimental Ticianelli et al. [28]. As shown in Fig. 4, the results predicted by the numerical are in good agreement with the experimental data.
Results
The study on the structural parameters of the bipolar plates, such as Wc, Ws, ϕ, ng, hp, and hc, which represent the channel width, support width, void fraction, height of support, and channel, respectively, has been done by using the Marr [15] model (Fig. 2). The amounts of other parameters are listed in Table 1.
Considering any structural changes in channels makes change in the amounts of pressure losses values, so it was assumed that its losses will be relieved by external tools and the pressure will be constant(5 bar). By comparing the results obtained from this research with other models and other sizes of the PEMs, it is revealed that these results are extendable for other fuel cells with any dimensions and structural and operational parameters.
Width of Channels (Wc).
According to obtained results, when the other parameters are constant and Wc is changed, the outlet voltage will be changed according to Fig. 5. As shown in this diagram, it is obvious that, when the number of channels or grooves in the plate is constant, the voltage increases with the decrease of Wc.
Of course, this change is very insignificant and, according to Fig. 6, the changes in Wc are more sensible in high current densities. It can be a good manner to increase total voltage in high current densities.
Figure 5 shows the change of voltage in variable sizes of channel width in ng = 12 and Iδ = 10 000 (A/m2). Figure 6 shows the voltage and power difference when Wc changes from 0.003 (m) to 0.00001 (m) and other parameters are constant.
More surface area is necessary in high current densities; however, when the width of channels decreases, the support area will increase.
The increment of the support area will change the void fraction of the electrode as compression decreases and consequently change the ability of reactant to diffusion to the catalyst surface directly underneath the support changes. So, with decreasing Wc, the ohmic resistance will decrease and also changes of void fraction of the electrode will have influence on cell voltage. The electrode void fraction influence on cell voltage will be discussed in Sec. 4.2.
Void Fraction.
Electrode void fraction is one of the important structural parameters that has influence on cell voltage. According to Marr [20], when void fraction in the electrode increases, mass transfer increases as well and, similarly, electrode resistance increases. The corresponding increase in resistivity from the increase of the electrode void fraction is swamped by increasing performance from better gas diffusion. As shown in Fig. 7, the increasing of the void fraction will lead to enhancement of cell voltage.
Width of Support (Ws).
According to Eq. (8), it can be seen that, for a constant number of channels in the bipolar plate with defined dimensions, Ws is increased as Wc decreases. So the outlet voltage is increased by increase of Ws, and this increase in voltage is due to the decrease of ohmic resistance in addition to changes in void fraction, like in Sec. 4.2. Also, this increase of outlet voltage, due to increase of Ws, is more obvious in high current densities.
Number of Channels (ng).
It was seen that the outlet voltage is increased because of decrease in Wc. Also, it is clear that, in high current densities, the effects of structural parameters are more sensible and more area of reaction is needed in these high current densities. Therefore, by increase of ng, the surface of contact can be increased, but on the other side, the width of supports will decrease by the increase of the number of channels. This causes changes in the void fraction and, accordingly, the ohmic resistance of the plate. Therefore, the number of channels must have an optimized amount. It has been clearly shown in Fig. 10. According to the voltage-ng diagram, it is obvious that, when ng increases in constant amounts of Wc and Iδ, the voltage increases and has a maximum amount in a definite amount for each size of Wc.
Height of Channels (hc).
Through obtained data by numerical solution method and according to Fig. 11, it is clear that, as hc (the height of channels shown in Fig. 2) is decreasing, the voltage is increased. This is due to the decrease of ohmic resistance. In this diagram, the number of channels used for the transfer of gas, the width of channel, and mass flow rate of channel are constant and hc is variable.
Also, in Fig. 12, the polarization curve for two different hc demonstrates the increase of voltage in higher current densities because of decreasing height of channels. That change in hc has more impact on outlet voltage in higher current densities.
Height of Support (hp).
By study effect of the height of supports, which is shown in Fig. 2, it is evident that, by reducing hp, the outlet voltage increases due to reduction of ohmic resistance. Figure 13 shows the influence of hp on the outlet voltage.
Other structural and operational parameters remain constant in the investigation of hp parameter.
Figure 14 shows the voltage and power difference when hp changes from 0.009 (m) to 0.00001 (m) and other parameters are constant.
Furthermore, it can be seen that the effect of the channel height is more sensible in high current densities, and according to Fig. 15, the effect of channel height is more sensible than the height of support on cell voltage.
Conclusion
By investigation of the isothermal, steady, and one-dimensional PEM fuel cell, it is shown that the present model is in excellent agreement with experimental data. Also, it was obtained that structural parameters of bipolar plates and the method of their designing and construction has impact on outlet voltage in high current densities. Also, the result indicates decreasing width of the gas channels, increasing outlet voltage. Similarly, it is evident that the height of channel, the height of support, and the number of gas channels has influence on outlet voltage. Also, the result shows that the contacting area of bipolar plates and the electrode and surface area of gas channels have great effect on the rate of reaction and, consequently, on cell voltage. Changes in the number of gas channels show that there are an optimum number of them for each size of channel width. Also, the increase in number of bipolar plate channels is not a benefit to reach maximum power density and depends on other parameters like contact area or width of channels and width of supports.